Posted by
mgraves on Wednesday, September 27, 2006 8:28:55 PM
I’m willing to stipulate, for the sake of argument, that the Iraq war is “creating” terrorists. What of it?
Iraq is an excuse. AQ did not need Iraq as recruiting tool. They’ve used U.S. support for Israel; U.S. oppression of Iraq in 1998; U.S. occupation of The Land of the Two Holy Places; and now, U.S. rejection of the Kyoto treaty, U.S. economic imbalance, U.S. budget deficit, and U.S. uninsured. If these guys want a justification, they’ll find it. If all else fails, they can hark back 900 years to the sack of Jerusalem, or 500 years to the Reconquista.
AQ turned from the Soviets to the U.S. (after UBL’s mentor, Azzam, met an unfortunate end by natural causes: a car bomb). This is the late 1980’s. We weren’t in Iraq yet, for anyone cursed with a public school education. We had assisted the mujahideen in Afghanistan, through Pakistan’s ISI (too bad we either did not know or did not care that ISI was basically a terrorist organization, supporting terrorists in Kashmir and creating the Taliban). Since then, we’ve intervened on behalf of Muslims in Bosnia and Kosovo. We’ve brought attention and pressure (far too little) on the Sudan on behalf of Muslims.
What we do has not a whit to do with why they would like us to die or submit. Who we are has everything to do with why they want us to die or submit. We are liberal (in the Walter Williams sense). We separate the state from religion. Hollywood makes vapid, stupid (and embarrassingly entertaining) movies and television shows.
Unless we are prepared to submit to dhimmitude, the Islamic fascists will find reasons to kill us. It is so easy to find justification these days: the culture of victim-hood and moral relativism make it easy to claim that one is merely responding in kind, even if the original harm was centuries ago. Those who live in “non-aligned” nations are permitted institutional memories that would put the proverbial elephant to shame. Any harm, at any time, committed by anyone is justification for the most horrible acts (on/off topic: Bob Mugabe destroying his country to reverse “imperialism” that he ignored for two decades)
If we were to leave Iraq now, in the misapprehension that so doing would make us safer, we would hand AQ not only a powerful recruiting tool, but a victory, which would have all kinds of repercussions:
"…If the Ummah is cleansed, then the glory of the Ummah will return. This is, according to VDH, one of the hallmarks of fascism (desire to return to a time of purity).
This is why any sign of weakness in the West is grasped by UBL (and Nasrallah, and Ahmadinejad...and Chavez, et cetera). It is an affirmation of their belief that they are becoming more pure and growing stronger than the West. It is a fulfillment of their belief that they are close to overthrowing the source of their problems and flaws."
(Good Lord, I just cited myself). We would be validating AQ’s belief of their eventual and imminent victory.
Andrew McCarthy at NRO has article discussing “terrorist creation” in light of our pre-Iraq war policy.
A key paragraph:
"Whether we wish to acknowledge it or not, jihadism is attractive to tens of millions of people in what is called the Muslim world. Out of a total population of about 1.3 billion, that may not be a very high percentage (although I daresay it is higher than we like to think). But it is the ideology that attracts recruits. Grievances are just rhetoric. If the bin [Ladins] did not have Iraq, or the Palestinians, or Lebanon, or Pope Benedict, or cartoons, or flushed Korans, or Dutch movies, or the Crusades, they’d figure out something else to beat the drums over. Or they’d make something up — there being lots of license to improvise when one purports to be executing Allah’s will."
Ideology is the driving force, and that ideology is Islamic fascism. Islam is the vehicle in which they drive and the excuse used to justify terrorism (it doesn’t help that the Medina verses—newer verses that abrogate older, peaceful Mecca verses—justify murder, rape, pillage, and dishonesty, cf. Serge Trifkovic, The Sword of the Prophet; Robert Spencer, Onward Muslim Soldiers; or Rev. Menezes, The Life and Religion of Mohammed).